On the 15th of March 2019, New Zealanders were faced with their first large-scale terrorist attack and consequent tragedy. A gunman attacked Christchurch’s Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Islamic Centre, murdering 51 people and harming 49 others in the name of white supremacy. The people of New Zealand and its government officials responded with a resounding, united voice against the actions of the alleged gunman, and support for the victims and their families has been forthcoming from the nation ever since. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern called the shooting “one of New Zealand’s darkest days”. The tragedy has touched the lives of many in New Zealand’s small country and internationally, because of such it is an intensely sensitive topic which must always be addressed with a great measure of respect and caution. For New Zealand’s journalists, this has presented an array of ethical dilemmas in regards to writing and reporting on the story, which is so deeply interwoven with an entire country’s shared trauma.
Before the attack commenced, the alleged gunman shared a 73-page manifesto of his beliefs online and sent a copy to 30 high-profile personnel, including the Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern. The alleged gunman also filmed and livestreamed the shooting with the use of a go-pro, which was then distributed by others extensively on social media. It has been speculated through observation of these actions that the alleged gunman aspired to draw attention to himself and his white supremacist ideologies. During press briefings in the wake of the attack, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Police Commissioner Mike Bush asked that New Zealanders did not embolden the alleged gunman by sharing the manifesto or the video of the attack. PM Ardern also stated that she would never say the name of the alleged attacker; “He is a terrorist. He is a criminal. He is an extremist. But he will, when I speak, be nameless”. She also called on New Zealanders to follow suit, “And to others I implore you: speak the names of those who were lost, rather than name of the man who took them. He may have sought notoriety, but we in New Zealand will give him nothing, not even his name.” Many New Zealanders have echoed and upheld this sentiment, and as a result naming the attacker has become a point of great ethical contention. While PM Ardern’s views are understandable, it must be recognized that while being charged the alleged gunman, Brenton Tarrant, waved the right to name suppression. Legally, news agencies and journalists may include Brenton Tarrant’s name in reporting where they see fit.
In preparation for Brenton Tarrant’s trial, senior editors from Mediaworks, TVNZ, Stuff, NZME and RNZ collaborated to produce an agreed upon set of guidelines which will be followed to insure that media coverage of the court proceedings is “comprehensive and responsible in the interests of open justice” (Ensor, 2019). At the release of these guidelines it was determined that the media would be naming Brenton Tarrant. This decision faced public backlash from those who believe doing so is immoral. However, journalistic principles of ethics present several potential arguments in the defense of naming Brenton Tarrant. Primarily, a journalists most crucial role is to act as a watchdog for society and a middleman between the people and their right to information (McQuail, 2013, p. 4). For a journalist to willingly and knowingly withhold facts from the public would be antithetical to this principle. In their role as middlemen between the people and their right to information, it is also greatly important that journalists report on matters of public interest (Harcup, 2015, p. 7). Because of the proximity of the terrorist attack to all New Zealanders, particularly the Muslim and Christchurch Community, and the amount of people who were impacted by the event, it is evident that the Christchurch shooting and the upcoming trial is a matter of great public interest. Information concerning the accused, including their name, will inevitably be addressed in court proceedings and thereby should be included in the subsequent reporting.
A common critique of journalism as a profession is that in reporting there is room for journalists to impose bias and thereby distort audiences points of view (Muhlmann, 2010, p. 12). For reporting to be ethical and efficient, any form of potential bias or opinion must not be present in published work. If New Zealand journalists were to omit the accused’s name in their reporting, it would exemplify a form of opinion. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s and other New Zealander’s unwillingness to speak Brenton Tarrant’s name is formulated on the principle that he is guilty and that he was seeking fame through his actions. Despite the mounting evidence against Brenton Tarrant, similar to all other criminals he is innocent until proven guilty. Choosing not to name Brenton Tarrant despite the presses legal right to do so would be an exceptional deviation from how accused persons are normally regarded by the media, in which they are most commonly named or not named on the basis of whether or not they have been granted name suppression, rather than whether or not the public sees it as morally acceptable to do so. Hal Crawford, chief news officer at Mediaworks, has stated that choosing to name Brenton Tarrant is a matter of not providing him with “special treatment”, and that the naming of both accused and convicted criminals is a cornerstone of open justice and free society. The senior editors of New Zealand’s foremost news agencies are of the singular mind that journalists have spent years defending their right to publish accused and convicted criminals names, and would not make an exception for Brenton Tarrant (Crawford, 2019).
While New Zealanders are unwilling to name Brenton Tarrant, out of the fear that doing so will provide him with the fame they consider he seeks, it is arguable that not naming him offers him precisely the notoriety they are trying to withhold. Never before in New Zealand’s history have news agencies been pressured by the public and government officials to suppress the name of an accused criminal who has waved that right. By treating Brenton Tarrant in a way which strays so severely from common journalism practice, the media would be elevating Brenton Tarrant to the status of super criminal, a man so evil he cannot be named, before he has been sentenced. Furthermore, for news agencies to neglect information as crucial as a name would be contradictory to journalisms primary role in society- to be the eyes and ears of the public.
References:
Crawford, H. (2019). Opinion: Why naming Brenton Tarrant is the right thing to do. Retrieved from Newshub: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2019/05/opinion-why-naming-brenton-tarrant-is-the-right-thing-to-do.html
Ensor, J. (2019). New Zealand media organisations agree to protocols for covering Christchurch terror attack trial. Retrieved from Newshub: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2019/04/new-zealand-media-organisations-agree-to-protocols-for-covering-christchurch-terror-attack-trial.html
Harcup, T. (2015). Journalism; principles and practice, 3rd edition. United States: Sage.
McQuail, D. (2013). Journalism and Society. United States: Sage.
Muhlmann, G. (2010). Journalism for democracy, English edition. Cambridge: Polity.











