Covering the Christchurch Mosque Shooting – An Ethical Dilemma

On the 15th of March 2019, New Zealanders were faced with their first large-scale terrorist attack and consequent tragedy. A gunman attacked Christchurch’s Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Islamic Centre, murdering 51 people and harming 49 others in the name of white supremacy. The people of New Zealand and its government officials responded with a resounding, united voice against the actions of the alleged gunman, and support for the victims and their families has been forthcoming from the nation ever since. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern called the shooting “one of New Zealand’s darkest days”. The tragedy has touched the lives of many in New Zealand’s small country and internationally, because of such it is an intensely sensitive topic which must always be addressed with a great measure of respect and caution. For New Zealand’s journalists, this has presented an array of ethical dilemmas in regards to writing and reporting on the story, which is so deeply interwoven with an entire country’s shared trauma.

Before the attack commenced, the alleged gunman shared a 73-page manifesto of his beliefs online and sent a copy to 30 high-profile personnel, including the Prime Minister, Jacinda Ardern. The alleged gunman also filmed and livestreamed the shooting with the use of a go-pro, which was then distributed by others extensively on social media. It has been speculated through observation of these actions that the alleged gunman aspired to draw attention to himself and his white supremacist ideologies. During press briefings in the wake of the attack, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Police Commissioner Mike Bush asked that New Zealanders did not embolden the alleged gunman by sharing the manifesto or the video of the attack. PM Ardern also stated that she would never say the name of the alleged attacker; “He is a terrorist. He is a criminal. He is an extremist. But he will, when I speak, be nameless”. She also called on New Zealanders to follow suit, “And to others I implore you: speak the names of those who were lost, rather than name of the man who took them. He may have sought notoriety, but we in New Zealand will give him nothing, not even his name.” Many New Zealanders have echoed and upheld this sentiment, and as a result naming the attacker has become a point of great ethical contention. While PM Ardern’s views are understandable, it must be recognized that while being charged the alleged gunman, Brenton Tarrant, waved the right to name suppression. Legally, news agencies and journalists may include Brenton Tarrant’s name in reporting where they see fit.

In preparation for Brenton Tarrant’s trial, senior editors from Mediaworks, TVNZ, Stuff, NZME and RNZ collaborated to produce an agreed upon set of guidelines which will be followed to insure that media coverage of the court proceedings is “comprehensive and responsible in the interests of open justice” (Ensor, 2019). At the release of these guidelines it was determined that the media would be naming Brenton Tarrant. This decision faced public backlash from those who believe doing so is immoral. However, journalistic principles of ethics present several potential arguments in the defense of naming Brenton Tarrant. Primarily, a journalists most crucial role is to act as a watchdog for society and a middleman between the people and their right to information (McQuail, 2013, p. 4). For a journalist to willingly and knowingly withhold facts from the public would be antithetical to this principle. In their role as middlemen between the people and their right to information, it is also greatly important that journalists report on matters of public interest (Harcup, 2015, p. 7).  Because of the proximity of the terrorist attack to all New Zealanders, particularly the Muslim and Christchurch Community, and the amount of people who were impacted by the event, it is evident that the Christchurch shooting and the upcoming trial is a matter of great public interest. Information concerning the accused, including their name, will inevitably be addressed in court proceedings and thereby should be included in the subsequent reporting.

A common critique of journalism as a profession is that in reporting there is room for journalists to impose bias and thereby distort audiences points of view (Muhlmann, 2010, p. 12). For reporting to be ethical and efficient, any form of potential bias or opinion must not be present in published work. If New Zealand journalists were to omit the accused’s name in their reporting, it would exemplify a form of opinion. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s and other New Zealander’s unwillingness to speak Brenton Tarrant’s name is formulated on the principle that he is guilty and that he was seeking fame through his actions. Despite the mounting evidence against Brenton Tarrant, similar to all other criminals he is innocent until proven guilty. Choosing not to name Brenton Tarrant despite the presses legal right to do so would be an exceptional deviation from how accused persons are normally regarded by the media, in which they are most commonly named or not named on the basis of whether or not they have been granted name suppression, rather than whether or not the public sees it as morally acceptable to do so. Hal Crawford, chief news officer at Mediaworks, has stated that choosing to name  Brenton Tarrant is a matter of not providing him with “special treatment”, and that the naming of both accused and convicted criminals is a cornerstone of open justice and free society.  The senior editors of New Zealand’s foremost news agencies are of the singular mind that journalists have spent years defending their right to publish accused and convicted criminals names, and would not make an exception for Brenton Tarrant (Crawford, 2019).

While New Zealanders are unwilling to name Brenton Tarrant, out of the fear that doing so will provide him with the fame they consider he seeks, it is arguable that not naming him offers him precisely the notoriety they are trying to withhold. Never before in New Zealand’s history have news agencies been pressured by the public and government officials to suppress the name of an accused criminal who has waved that right. By treating Brenton Tarrant in a way which strays so severely from common journalism practice, the media would be elevating Brenton Tarrant to the status of super criminal, a man so evil he cannot be named, before he has been sentenced. Furthermore, for news agencies to neglect information as crucial as a name would be contradictory to journalisms primary role in society- to be the eyes and ears of the public.

References:

Crawford, H. (2019). Opinion: Why naming Brenton Tarrant is the right thing to do. Retrieved from Newshub: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2019/05/opinion-why-naming-brenton-tarrant-is-the-right-thing-to-do.html

Ensor, J. (2019). New Zealand media organisations agree to protocols for covering Christchurch terror attack trial. Retrieved from Newshub: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/new-zealand/2019/04/new-zealand-media-organisations-agree-to-protocols-for-covering-christchurch-terror-attack-trial.html

Harcup, T. (2015). Journalism; principles and practice, 3rd edition. United States: Sage.

McQuail, D. (2013). Journalism and Society. United States: Sage.

Muhlmann, G. (2010). Journalism for democracy, English edition. Cambridge: Polity.

Single-Use Plastic Bags Banned: How Different Audiences Were Targeted To Tell The Story

By Demelza Jackson

Picture1.png

“Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and children from Petone College picking up rubbish after the announcement of the single-use plastic bag ban.” (Tindiller, 2018)

The world of broadcasting is fast-paced and always evolving. Technological advancements and the ever-growing popularity of social media continue to provide more delivery options, from broadcaster to audience, across a variety of platforms. Subsequently, new outlets are being utilised to go beyond the traditional form of broadcasting, and to maximise audience usage and engagement. This essay will use the breaking news story of the 2018 single-use plastic bag ban to exemplify the way broadcaster Radio New Zealand (RNZ) have used a variety of platforms to reach different audiences; including traditional radio, social media and their website.

The Labour Government’s announcement that single-use plastic bags would be phased out over the course of the next year is a breaking news story, and can be defined as such because it incorporates a variety of news values. Harcup and O’Neill (2017, p. 1470) explain that news values are the standards and criteria which journalists refer to, which define the importance and newsworthiness of a story. The single-use plastic bag ban encompasses the news values of impact, immediacy and proximity. It is also a breaking news story surrounded in some conflict, as the ban has been met with both critique and praise (Brighton & Foy, 2007, p. 14).

Radio New Zealand has an obligation as a broadcaster to reach as many New Zealanders as possible, as they are recognised as a crown entity and the “designated Lifeline Utility radio broadcaster in the event of a civil defence emergency”. Their recognised demographic, being members of the public over the age of 10, exemplifies the expansiveness of their reach, as well as their weekly nationwide cumulative audience of 682,700 (Radio New Zealand, 2018). Due to their prestige as a crown entity and their large demographic, RNZ have had to utilise a multi-platform dynamic to ensure that their content is mutually accessible and has a wide audience reach (Doyle, 2010, p. 4).

RNZ used traditional radio as one of many platforms, to both break and expand upon the single-use plastic bag ban story. Due to their 10+ demographic, RNZ’s main concern while covering the story throughout the day was providing unbiased and relevant facts that were accessible for listeners of all ages. The story was broken on the 2pm news bulletin, and later summarised and expanded upon later in the broadcast, at 5pm on John Campbell’s radio show “Checkpoint”. The segment focused largely on the Governments reasoning for passing the bill, with Campbell quoting the evidence supplied during the briefing alongside soundbites to provide credibility.  The segment also had audio from members of the public who were interviewed on the matter, which stressed the proximity of the ban, regarding the way it effects the conventional New Zealand citizen. Members of the public from school-aged children to adults were used in the audio interviewing process, which exemplifies the way RNZ incorporates its 10+ audience. Listen to the Checkpoint segment here.

Facebook is another platform which RNZ utilised to break the story to the public in a timely manner. Data shows that 850,000 of New Zealander’s use Facebook, making it a necessary platform to employ for broadcasters to expand their audience range and engagement (Statista, 2018). RNZ’s Facebook page has a large following of 81,000 people, providing RNZ with a significant amount of their audience reach (https://www.facebook.com/RadioNewZealand/). After their bulletin announcement on traditional radio, Facebook is the second place where RNZ broke the story, using a 1-minute video with a summary of the event, and a short-written description to cover the pertinent information relevant to the single-use plastic bag ban. Video is a popular medium used to break news on Facebook, as the Facebook algorithm favours video due to their auto-play mechanism- which collects views quickly. The “short and sweet” style of the video also works to effectively target the Facebook audience, as viewers are only made to engage for a short while but are still able to pick up key facts. Viewers are also able to share the video easily with their peers, which expands RNZ’s reach to their 10+ audience. Watch the video here.

Picture1.png

Picture2.png

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RNZ’s Twitter page has 37,900 followers, making it another integral platform to utilise in reaching as much of their 10+ audience as possible. Much of RNZ’s Twitter content is designed to redirect their follower’s attention to articles posted to their website with the use of short, attention-grabbing captions and relevant pictures linking to articles. Statistics show that 604,253 of RNZ’s audience get their news through interaction with RNZ’s articles posted to their website. The articles posted to the RNZ twitter page exemplify the accessibility and widespread appeal of RNZ’s content and coverage of events. Concerning the single-use plastic bag ban, RNZ posted two articles to their twitter page focusing on two different angles of the story, one of which detailed the possible negatives of the ban (read it here), and one which detailed the potential positives of the ban (read it here). By posting two angles to the story, RNZ insure that their coverage of the event is unbiased, remains politically neutral and targets their 10+ demographic as widely as possible, regardless of members of the publics political inclinations.

Screen Shot 2018-08-16 at 3.23.50 PM.pngScreen Shot 2018-08-16 at 3.23.33 PM.png

 

 

 

 

 

 

Due to both their expansive audience and their obligations as a journalistic broadcaster, it is in Radio New Zealand’s interest to utilise multi-media platforms and a variety of outlets so they can best reach their 10+ audience demographic. In the fast paced and ever changing world of broadcasting, Radio New Zealand incorporate the usage of traditional radio broadcasting, social media and website articles to ensure that their target audience reach is expansive. This can be recognised through their coverage of the breaking news story of the Government announcing a single-use plastic bag ban.

 

“What is News?” and my development as a journalist

By Demelza Jackson

Over the course of my journalism studies this year, I have had the pleasure of finding, researching, writing and editing a variety of my own stories. Throughout this process, my understanding of what makes a newsworthy story and the purpose and value of journalism has developed greatly. This knowledge of journalism has aided me in creating an understanding of how my own work fits into the wider news eco-system, as I work to ensure that what I produce can be considered academically valuable and fits the credentials of what makes for a good story. This multi-media essay will discuss the purpose of journalism, the values which define what makes a story news worthy, the definition of news from an academic standpoint and the definition of news from a consumer’s standpoint. Throughout this essay, I will provide links to a variety of news texts which I have consumed throughout the semester, all of which help to establish an understanding of what “news” is.

My appreciation of the role of journalism in society has deepened greatly throughout my studies, and it is under this knowledge of what a journalist seeks to accomplish that I have carried out my work. The role of journalism can be defined into two primary roles: a journalist should seek to contribute to a well-informed society, and act as a watchdog which upholds the publics interests (Zuniga & Hinsley, 2013, p. 928). Journalists fulfil these roles by seeking out and bringing to light information which can be defined as “within the public’s interest to know” and ensuring that said information is readily available and accessible to the general masses. Croteau and Hoynes (2001) expand upon this idea, explaining that the information which journalists provide is significant and necessary as it helps the public make sense of the world in which they live. This established purpose guides the content which journalists produce, and examples of this can be found widely amongst a variety of news publications. Political journalism and civil announcement journalism are prime examples of news stories which fit this brief, as both provide information which immediately effects the public. The 2017 New Zealand election was an event which sparked constant media attention, as every detail of the election and the resulting success of the Labour government was broadcast to the New Zealand populace. The resulting media content are all examples of public service journalism, and a variety of national news sources can be referenced as contributors. The NZ Herald, a national news media conglomerate, was one of many to report the results of the election immediately both in paper and on their news website. The report, titled “Election 2017: Results at a glance” (2017) is straightforward and to the point, providing the information which New Zealand citizens needed to know immediately, a link is provided here: https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11925792. Stuff News (2017) also wrote a similar report, which can be found here: https://interactives.stuff.co.nz/NZ-election-home/. Political journalism within New Zealand is a facet of the news industry which interests me greatly, and much of my own work over my time studying journalism both this year and last concerned political and social activism and other political affairs. A story which I recently wrote about the last National governments reported mismanagement of the Kauri Dieback programme is a personal favorite of mine, and it was inspired by my beliefs that the public has a right to political information. A link to that article can be found here: https://demelzajackson.wordpress.com/2018/05/17/kauri-dieback-programme-faces-accusations-of-mismanagement/.

When studying journalism, and learning how to write a story of interest, there are a set of requirements which a budding writing should continually refer to- and which helped me to determine whether a story I was investigating was worthy of putting to paper. These requirements are referred to as “news values”, and have been developed over time by a vast number of scholars since their original inception in 1965 to define what makes a story “News worthy”. Galtang and Ruge defined these news values originally as the following: Timeliness, simplification, predictability, unexpectedness, continuity, composition, elite people, elite nations and negativity (Brighton & Foy, 2007, p. 14). An enticing news story could be made up of any number of these differing news values, and need not include every value to be deemed news worthy. For example, a story cannot be both predictable and unexpected- but a story which was foreseen can be as esteemed as a story which is bizarre and out of the ordinary. Also, not every story needs to reference an elite story to be interesting, I have since learned that there are plenty of interesting news stories concerning the average person. Continuity is an interesting news value, and stories which develop over time usually draw much public attention, as more people tune in to the story the longer it goes on and as more is revealed. An example of an event which garnered much media attention were the allegations of sexual assault, rape and professional misconduct which began to pile up against Harvey Weinstein in 2017 and spilled out into 2018. As time went on, more information of Weinstein, as well as further allegations of his misconduct were brought to light and the story gained traction. The Weinstein story has been picked up by a variety of different publications, and when analyzed it can be determined that it fits many of the news values. The story was timely as allegations are still coming forward (timeliness), the story is easy to explain (simplification), the general populace was surprised by the allegations (unexpectedness), the story has continued over an extended period (continuity) and the story involves various celebrities (elite persons). The Guardian is a news outlet which has followed the story closely, their most recent article on the topic details one of Weinstein’s alleged victims, Lysette Anthony’s, anticipation for the trial against Weinstein and provides information on the #metoo movement which began in support of Weinstein’s alleged victims. A link to this article can be found here: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jun/02/lysette-anthony-welcomes-start-of-harvey-weinstein-trial.

From an academic standpoint, and from the viewpoint of journalists, there are a variety of concepts which come together to define what constitutes news. Much of what academically defines news media and journalism has already been defined in this essay, but there are still more concepts which contribute to the academic understanding of journalism which I have developed over my course of study so far. First and foremost, we have the aforementioned role of the journalist, which defines much of the content which we find in the news, referring back to Croteau and Haynes’ (2001) statement that the information journalists provide helps the public to better understand the world they live in. We also have established the idea of the news values, which help a journalist to decide what is an academically newsworthy story. There are a few more journalistic values which must be mentioned however, as they greatly influence what news is and how it is produced. Principal traits which journalists value in their work, and which I have sought to exemplify throughout my own work, include objectivity, autonomy and accuracy (Zuniga & Hinsley, 2013, p. 927). These values dictate that for a journalist to produce reliable and respectable news, the articles they write must be without bias, factually accurate and unhindered by any political association. Especially within the realm of political journalism, writing without bias can be challenging. As I myself enjoy writing about politics, but have deeply held political beliefs, writing without bias throughout the year has been a challenge I have faced (Particularly in my previously mentioned article concerning the National governments alleged mismanagement of the Kauri Dieback programme) but ultimately believe I have been able to overcome. Patrick Gower is an esteemed and respected political journalist who I believe represents these values and whose commentary I have enjoyed greatly on a variety of different platforms, including his social media platforms such as twitter (https://twitter.com/patrickgowernz?lang=en) and his segments on NewsHub. Here is an article written by Patrick Gower, detailing PM Jacinda Ardern banning of the use of private investigators for government spying: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/03/pm-jacinda-ardern-bans-private-investigators-behind-southern-response-spying.html. I enjoyed this article for its factuality, accuracy and lack of bias.

Largely, this essay has focused on defining what news is from an academic standpoint, and has related heavily to the values which journalists seek to uphold and emulate in their work. As a novice journalist, and an aspiring academic I have attempted in my own writing to represent these values so that my own work may support and cooperate with the wider news ecosystem. However, while I am inclined to consider news from an academic standpoint, it has also been of importance to consider news from the consumers view, so that my understanding of news and journalism may be as socially relevant as is possible. A case study by Armstrong et al. (2015) sought to answer the question of whether audiences had a different answer to the question “what is news” than what is academically accepted. Based off the news values, a study was carried out on a group of 596 young adults to determine what is considered news in a contemporary setting. Of the results, it was determined that two of the news values, being timeliness and proximity are not considered as important to audiences as they are academically to journalists. The study also found that the news values of prominence, unusualness, impact and controversy were rated as more news worthy by respondents (Armstrong et al., 2015, p. 93). I disagree with the sentiment that timeliness and proximity are not as important as the other news values, even when I was simply a consumer and not a journalism student. I greatly enjoy local news, which relies heavily on proximity- and find news from small, local news agencies and magazines to be as valuable as global news conglomerates. ‘The Fringe’ is a magazine which publishes news relevant to the Titirangi area, which I call home. I have taken great pleasure in reading news about my local community my whole life. There is an article about the Titirangi Festival in there which I particularly appreciated: https://issuu.com/fringemedia8/docs/1805.

My journalism studies have provided me with an understanding of journalism and news from both an academic and a consumer standpoint of which I am greatly appreciative. It is with this understanding that I have attempted to write articles which can be considered valuable, and provide useful information to my audiences. My academic understanding of journalism encompasses the traits and aspects which define newsworthy and reliable stories. These aspects including the role of journalism, both as watchdogs and as contributors to an informed society, the various news values which have been developed over an extensive period of time and the personal values and traits which journalists uphold within their work- accuracy, objectivity and autonomy. My studies have also helped me to create an understanding of the values which audiences view important and that create news worthy stories. It is with this information that I have learned over the semester that I have produced my work, with the hopes of contributing to the wider news media ecosystem.

 

References:

Armstrong, C. & McAdams, M. & Cain, J. (2015). What Is News? Audiences May Have Their Own Ideas, Atlantic Journal of Communication, 23:2, 81-98, DOI: 10.1080/15456870.2015.1013102

Brighton, P. & Foy, D. (2007). News Values. London: thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

Croteau, David, and William Hoynes. (2001). The Business of Media: Corporate Media and the Public Interest. Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press.

Gower, P. (May 12, 2018). PM Jacinda Ardern bans private investigators behind Southern Response spying. Retrieved From: https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2018/03/pm-jacinda-ardern-bans-private-investigators-behind-southern-response-spying.html

Jackson, D. (May 17, 2018).  Kauri Dieback Programme faces accusations of mismanagement. Retrieved from: https://demelzajackson.wordpress.com/2018/05/17/kauri-dieback-programme-faces-accusations-of-mismanagement/

NZ Herald. (Sep 24, 2017). Election 2017: Results at a glance. Retrieved from: https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11925792

Stuff. (Sep 24, 2017). Election 2017: Final Results. Retrieved from: https://interactives.stuff.co.nz/NZ-election-home/

The Guardian. (Jun 2, 2018). Lysette Anthony welcomes start of Harvey Weinstein trial. Retrieved from: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jun/02/lysette-anthony-welcomes-start-of-harvey-weinstein-trial

The Fringe. (May 1, 2018). The Fringe: issue 170. Retrieved From: https://issuu.com/fringemedia8/docs/1805

Zúñiga, H. & Hinsley, A. (2013) The Press Versus the Public, Journalism Studies, 14:6, 926-942, DOI: 10.1080/1461670X.2012.744551

V-Gals Goes Global

By Demelza Jackson

Non-profit organisation ‘V-gals’ has announced it will go global with its brand this year to direct more attention to its vegan campaign.

V-gals established themselves at the end of 2017 with the release of their first charitable calendar: “V-Gals Nude in Nature”. The young women, all vegan activists, posed nude to create the calendar in the hopes of garnering attention from the public toward their cause, and raising money for The Animal Sanctuary.

The first release of calendars sold out and by the end of sales, the V-gals had raised $675 in profit for The Animal Sanctuary. Their organization also received notable media attention from ‘The Rock’ radio and TVNZ ‘Re:’ news.

29-year-old co-founder and activist Alyssa Salmon says that next year they are “hoping for bigger and better things” and believes globalizing V-gals will help them reach that goal.

The idea to globalize was introduced after Salmon was approached by a kiwi-born vegan activist living in America.

“She came to me and said, ‘how would you feel about franchising V-gals because there is a huge market over here and I’ve got lots of vegan girls that are keen to get on board’ and I thought ‘why not, why wouldn’t we?’ It’s not for profit for us, it’s all for profit for the animals so why wouldn’t I want to expand that?”

A model for the calendar, Yume Lhamo, adds that globalizing would make the calendar “less personal to our local community” but thinks that other countries becoming involved “would be awesome”. She also said that she appreciated that the first calendar was “home grown”.

The calendar received both positive and negative reviews, as some members of the vegan community viewed the actions of the V-Gals as “exploitative”.

However, Salmon is not fazed by critics, and her response to them is: “there is already enough hate in the world […] go do something productive, that’s what we’re trying to do. We don’t need any more hate, we need more life.”Picture1.png

Co-founders Alyssa Salmon and Sasha Ogle-Tree (Left to Right) posing together for the July page of the calendar.

Kauri Dieback Programme faces accusations of mismanagement

By Demelza Jackson

Accusations that the Kauri Dieback Programme has been mismanaged by the responsible government agency have been raised by environmentalists.

During an environment select committee meeting held on the 10th of May, evidence was submitted which alleges that the programme, which aims to fight the spread of the Kauri Dieback disease, has been neglected by the Ministry for Primary Industries.

Deborah Russell, MP for New Lynn, acted as chair for the briefing. Russell says that there were several strong criticisms made against MPI.

“There is talk of a lack of coordination, a lack of focus on critical issues, on funding not flowing through to where it should go and that the tangata whenua had not been consulted.”

“The tangata whenua, who are working with MPI, said to us that they have only been used as decoration. That they were brought in only when MPI needed them to dress something up.”

Dr Mels Barton, Secretary for The Tree Council and Titirangi Resident says that MPI have failed to take the disease seriously and believes not enough has been done in the past decade to stop the disease from spreading.

“The entire program has been completely mismanaged, and has ground to a halt effectively. Nothing much has happened over the last four or five years.”

“They are using a method of surveillance which is not peer reviewed and has no scientific credibility. It’s known not to be accurate.”

“The reason why I am focused on the surveillance is you are trying to contain a biosecurity incursion which is moving. If you do not know where that is, or where the infected or healthy trees are, how do you know which action you need to take to contain it?”

“It makes the rest of the programme a farce, if you do not actually know where this organism is.”

Barton says that there are four biosecurity questions which MPI are tasked with answering.

“What it is, where it is, how do you kill it, and what else does it infect. And out of those four questions only ‘what it is’ has been answered.”

“It’s very unlikely it only infects Kauri, which is why the ‘what else does it infect’ question is so important […] you don’t know what other trees it might kill once it gets up to a certain level in the soil.”

On the 1st of May, the forested areas of the Waitakere Ranges were closed to the public in attempts to contain the Kauri Dieback disease.

 

IMG_2186.jpg

MP for New Lynn, Deborah Russell at her office in Glen Eden.

 

 

The End of Life Choice Bill: An issue of ableism

By Demelza Jackson

Public submissions have closed for the ‘End of Life Choice Bill’, but advocates for disability rights stress that the debate is not over, calling for better representation of their concerns on the bill.

The bill, which details that persons with terminal and life-long grievous and irremediable disabilities or illness may choose to end their life through euthanasia, has been the cause of significant political and public debate since David Seymour, leader of the Act party, introduced it in June of 2017.

Advocates for disability rights have since expressed the fear that the bill will pose a serious threat for disabled people’s human rights and their autonomy.

Dr Huhana Hickey, a scholar of disability research and legal theory, suggests that due to controversial practices which have occurred in other countries where euthanasia is legal, the bill runs the risk of making disabled persons similarly vulnerable to coercion, encouraging them to end their lives early to avoid becoming a “liability to society”.

Hickey believes that the voices of the disabled have not been fairly represented.

“We are a high risk, (disabled people) have no political power and no position of power and so as a community we are marginalised, oppressed and ‘invisibilised’, due to peoples fear of disability and an assumption we become economic burdens.”

Hickey explains that a major concern for herself and other disabled persons is that there will be a “lack of support” for disabled and terminally ill people who choose to live, and stresses the importance of focusing on solutions other than euthanasia.

“David’s bill does not take into account that some of us don’t want to end our lives, due to pain and disability [..] he also has no provision on how to provide other options as well such as palliative care and supports and services for the disabled.”

While Hickey’s sentiments on the issue are shared widely, it does not signify the views of everybody in the disabled community.

Morgaina Matthias, a 30-year-old woman who has lived with the rare condition Ataxia Telangiectasia her whole life, expresses the importance of allowing allegeable people the right to choose for themselves.

“I don’t find (the bill) offensive. As a disabled person, if you are really suffering, it’s up to you as a person. Even though it might be hard for others who are looking after you, I still think you should have the right to decide yourself.”

The bill is currently in the select committee stage.

IMG_1947

Morgaina Matthias, a 30-year-old woman with Ataxia Telangiectasia, is an advocate for allowing disabled persons the freedom of choice in relation to euthanasia.

Compromises made as Watercare seek to placate Titirangi protestors

By Demelza Jackson

After a month-long protest by Titirangi residents, Watercare has agreed to meet concessions regarding the placement of their new water treatment plant in Waima.

The new treatment facility, which will be placed on Manuka Rd, will cost Watercare an estimated $317 million.

The water treatment plant was originally announced to be placed Oratia, but large-scale protesting from locals caused Watercare to back down and pick a new location.

However, Since the announcement of the treatment plants location, Titirangi locals have voiced concerns about the environmental consequence of the facility on the native bush, the felling of Kauri trees has been a point of major contention. Residents of the area also fear potential disruption to the area during the construction process and loss of the Clark Bush track. Greg Presland, chairman of the Waitakere ranges local board and Titirangi resident explains that:

“People don’t want to see a large industrial scale complex in their backyard, so the question of size is important and placement is important. And the amount of bush that is going to be cleared is very important”.

“I’ve always been very protective of the bush”.

img_0450-e1508372972586.jpg

               A protest placard in Titirangi Village.

img_0443.jpg

               Protest sign placed on the Titirangi Village roundabout.

The locals have displayed their dismay in the form of a 300 person sit-in and march, which took place in early June. Placards have appeared throughout Titirangi imploring Watercare to leave Waima alone and petitions and videos have circulated online as protestors take to social media to rally sympathisers to their cause.

1496657240957

           300 protestors march to protect Waima Bush. Picture courtesy of Jacinda Boyd.

This is not Titirangi local’s first incident of environmental activism. In 2015 locals rallied against the felling of a 100-year old Kauri on a Paturoa Rd property, which was to be cut down to make room for building development. The tree was occupied by Protestor Jonno Smith until the property owner agreed not to cut it down.

Mr Presland comments that in Titirangi there is “always someone willing to climb in” to save a Kauri tree.

In response to the protestors, a board meeting, attended by Titirangi residents and Watercare representatives was held in June and three riders were added to the draft resolution to consolidate displeased locals.

“Watercare is to seek to minimise environmental damage, it is to lodge the application for a resource consent through Council so that the opportunity for local people to have a say is maximised and there is to be enhanced consultation with the local community.”

Mr Presland acted as the go-between for protestors and Watercare representatives.

“Watercare is a big, self-controlled organisation with a $5bn balance sheet and huge access to resources and professional advice. Local people and communities can access good quality advice but it’s much more difficult for them to do that. There was a very clear power imbalance.”

“The protesting has been (effective). Watercare has taken a step back and set up this consultation comity with local people and that comity has a lot of moral strength behind it.”

“It does appear that Watercare is prepared to adjust and change its position on various points.”

Mr Presland has stated that he will wait until he has seen the final design from Watercare to decide whether he is satisfied with the concessions made during the board meeting.

For more information:

  • Greg Presland’s report on the board meeting.
  • More information on the protests.
  • A petition to stop Watercare from building the treatment plant.
  • Online response to Watercare felling Kauri trees.
  • Full audio from the interview with Greg Presland.
  • Personal Twitter.

 

 

Utilising Social Media

Throughout my investigation of the Watercare scandal, social media was prolific in my search for information. The Titirangi Facebook page, a private group where Titirangi locals can engage in discourse and discussion, was a cesspool of opinions, arguments and facts to wade through. My access to this page has been highly beneficial, as I’ve received insight into the community issue which will help to flesh out plenty of issues which shall arise in my news story.

However, in using social media to divulge information I have had to adjust and train my critical eye. While plenty of the posts and threads I analysed were helpful and insightful, there were just as many incidences of alternative facts, misleading details and biased judgements. Christian Fuchs guide “Social Media: A Critical Introduction” was a reading which I found exceptionally useful to utilise whilst sifting through all of the information I collected.

With a semester of readings, lectures and tutorials under my belt I now have a plethora of knowledge which I shall use to put together this story. I have learned how to identify a news worthy story, how to pick my angle, how to investigate and collect relevant information, how to interview and how to do all of the above in the most ethical way possible. Now it is time to put my new-found knowledge to good use.

References:

Fuchs, C. (2014). Social Media: A critical Introduction. Los Angeles: Sage.

Making the Story ‘News’

Today we revisit the concept of news values and angles, after reading Andy Bull’s handbook “Multimedia Journalism: A Practical Guide”. Bull analyses various news stories in order to make a point about what makes for good news, and how best to present it. He stresses the importance of introducing the “news” aspect within the first 25-words, and explains within these 25-words the most immediate and important facts must be presented (2015, p. 5).

After some consideration and analysis of my own news story, I have realised that writing about the event of the protesting alone is not necessarily news. While it is current, there are many accessible sources available already which detail the protestors actions. While I will still include this aspect within my story, as it is such a large part of the issue, I want to instead focus mainly on the negotiation process which has gone on between Watercare and the people which has been mediated by the chairman of the Waitakere ranges local board: Greg Presland. The dialogue between the two parties is very interesting to analyse as it reflects what they are willing to make concessions on, and what they will not.

References:

Bull, A. (2015). Multimedia Journalism : A Practical Guide. UK: Taylor & Francis.

Collecting the Evidence

It is my personal belief that there has never been an easier time to be a journalist. In our modern world, the tools we need to capture in the moment proof or quickly produce a news announcement are always close at hand. This week, we focused on the production of multi-media story telling using a smart-phone. The smart-phone is an incredibly useful device for a journalist, as Ivo Burum and Stephen Quinn explain in their 2015 book “Mojo: The mobile journalism Handbook” how a smart-phone may be used to film audio and video proof, take the most effectual photographs and even edit the collected evidence on your device.

For my own story, it will be important that I collect evidence which provides a clear reflection of the conviction of the protestors. I also wish to capture the beauty of the Titirangi native bush, so I can truly show readers who aren’t familiar with the area why the locals are so protective of the land. I think a video of the Titirangi bush will work effectively for this, which I will include in my final story. Luckily, even more protest signs have sprung up around Titirangi- I will include one below. Photo taken myself.

img_04491.jpg

Also, while searching the internet for examples of video journalism- I found a very interesting video a man made on his smartphone expressing his dismay at Watercare. View it here.

References:

Burum, I. & Quinn, S. (2015). MOJO: The mobile journalism handbook: how to make broadcast videos with an iPhone or iPad. UK: Taylor & Francis.